Whale Update

Just thought I’d post a quick follow-up to the controversy surrounding whales. I wrote about my first (and probably last) experience eating whale meat and my thoughts on the modern practice of whaling – especially in Japan – in my post Whale of a Tale. Well, I caught this update thanks to JapanProbe and its daily aggregation of newsworthy bits and blurbs. Apparently, the Japanese media has been discussing the rise in the populations of Humpback, Minke, and Blue whales. The blog David @ Tokyo posted about these reports. Please visit his post about Southern Hemisphere Humpbacks, his post about Antarctic Blue Whales, and his entry that JapanProbe picked up.

Basically, the Japanese media is reporting that the IUCN Red List people are giving thought to reclassification of a couple of types of whales. David translated the Yomiuri Shinbun’s article about it. I have reproduced David’s translation below.

Humpback and Minke, removed from “Endangered” list – New impetus for whaling resumption

It has been learnt that the IUCN, after confirming increases in the number of Humpback and Minke whales which had been threatened with extinction, has moved to down list these two species to a lower rank of extinction risk.

The downgrade is expected to be published shortly in the “Red List”, which classifies animal species by different levels of extinction risk. Coming on the eve of the annual meeting of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) in Anchorage USA, the controversy surrounding the resumption of commercial whaling for these two species is likely to be heightened.

According to the Red List, the Humpback was “Endangered (Threatened)”, and the Minke whale species, while not meeting the criteria of a Threatened species, had been classified in the “Near Threatened” category, requiring caution, due to a notable decreasing trend in their numbers.

The IUCN, in progressing their re-evaluation of the rankings for the world’s mammal species, held a meeting of specialists in January this year, and confirmed that they would downgrade the Humpback and Minke whale species to “Least Concern”, a ranking indicating a low risk of extinction, based on scientific data such as that provided by the research whaling conducted by Japan.

The research whaling is currently conducted with respect to Minke whales, and from this autumn will commence for Humpback whales. This downgrade will potentially provide the nations who are aiming for a resumption in commercial whaling, such as Japan, with a powerful reinforcement. Yoshio Kaneko of Iwate Prefectural University’s Faculty of Policy Studies commented that “This is the result of an objective judgement of the status of whale abundance. With respect to these two species, anti-whaling advocates will lose any grounds they had to say that these whales are facing extinction”.

(2007/4/27/ 3:10 Yomiuri Shinbun)

(Read the original.)

Wish I’d found David’s blog a lot earlier. He posts tons of stuff about whaling in Japan. I’ll be following it with interest. Thanks, David! :-)

  • Facebook
  • email
  • Technorati
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks

Deas Customary Drivel, Unsolicited Commentary

Hit JapanSoc.com today for the best social news about Japan!
Loading...
  • Zuzu Elf
    who you callin' a troll? just so's you know-csi had a good finale (cliffhanger...) and the decision on whether or not I continue to watch the show will be decided in september after the first episode of season 8. If they kill off sara, i'm dropping it like rotting whale carcass. (hey, i'm posting on the whale one, so i had to tie it in somehow)
    miss you. lots and lots.
  • I can't believe my own twin is a troll on my blog...how awesome is that?? Ha ha ha. :-) I'm sorry about CSI. I haven't seen it since last summer...I did, however, buy 24 via iTunes. Not that I can boast about it - this season has been LAME compared to the past seasons. Then again, it's got to be hard to repeatedly top yourself.
  • Ernie the one eyed whaler
    After thinking long and hard about my future and what I want to make of myself and all, I have decided that I want to become a whaler.

    as a side note: I am VERY frustrated with the writers of CSI and want to throttle them after last night's episode. If I don't get my good ending/beginning(of season 8) I just might harpoon some of them!!! hey...there's an idea... ;o)
  • And then there's Alex, always coming in with a timely ridiculous statement. Ha ha ha. :-) You're looking for trouble, aren't you?
  • There are too many whales. That's why they commit suicide by hurling themselves into oncoming vessels.
  • Hey there, David. I'd just to say that your comments are just as awesome as your blog. I'd call it a whale of a comment, but that might be way too puntastic for everyone. In fact, I just winced at myself for admitting to thinking about it.

    I am shocked that I didn't come across your blog way back when I posted the first time. I checked Technorati and everything for other blogs and came up blank. I'm really glad that James was onto you.

    I agree with you on the in-person "party foul" type response to discussing whaling. It's ridiculous, but unfortunately true. I was thrilled to find that there are other people who think this is an absurd thing to be angry and activistic about. (I know that's not a real word, but I wanted to say "vehemently opposed to in the fashion of activists" in a single swipe.)

    Like I said, I'll follow your blog with interest. It's good stuff. Thanks for popping by. :-) Weird coincidences about your fiancee (congrats) and JET...weird, but cool.
  • Hi guys,

    Thanks for the positive feedback - much appreciated!

    Whaling does tend to incite the wrath of many out there, and in person I often hesitate to discuss the issue or speak my mind with non-Japanese for fear of ruining the atmosphere :) I've posted strongly opinionated stuff a lot on my blog in the past, but when it attracts an eruption of responses (once from Greenpeace in Jan 2006) it tends to take a lot of time, patience and energy for probably little gain. It's just so repetitive - this is a debate that goes no where.

    With the example you raised, the "whales are endangered" dogma, no matter how many times the falsehood is pointed out, has been repeated so much that it's "common knowledge", and it unfortunately seems to have the critical mass to perpetuate itself. Even say your average kiwi, aussie, or british person were to get a better understanding of the true situation - at the end of the day whaling doesn't effect them and so it drops off their radar, and will never see political change come about because of it.

    My estimation is that the majority of people are OK with exploitation of wild natural resources if it is executed on a sustainable basis (my personal stance as well). Other groups of people believe in animal rights, or are anti-cruelty (judging our interactions with whales as being "cruel" or "inhumane" by some kind of arbitrary standard), that whales are equivalents of humans and thus a "special case" or other even more minor ideas. I've wasted too much time with these people - their opinions are to be respected, but ultimately we have different values and thus can never come to any agreement.

    But anti-whaling governments still have domestic constituencies full of people with those "minor" types of opinions about whales, belief that their personal ethics are superior, and even more people who believe that "whales are endangered". And hardly any people who would vote for a government that did a 180 and decided to support whaling.

    So, with the political deadlock, I think the end of the IWC is inevitable. I personally think Japanese officials are setting up for a withdrawal or change of course by June 2008 if the IWC fails this year to show signs of change. The USA sometimes gives indications of showing some leadership for change, but ultimately my guess is that they weigh up the political risk versus the conservation risk, and put their faith in the whaling nations not to go crazy, by maintaining their "no-whaling" stance, and forcing Japan to quit the IWC or whatever. At the official level they know it won't spell disaster in the short/medium term.

    As for the blog, these days I try to post more information, and less (repetitive and potentially pointless) opinion:
    - status of the Japanese whale meat market (my personal favourite, as the western media has is reporting the opposite of the situation that I observe)
    - status of various whale populations
    - the odd bit about management (i.e., Revised Management Procedure related stuff)
    - other incidents of interest

    Deas, my fiancee is from Ehime and used to work for the Board of Education there :) I did JET as well, a few years back :)
  • David's blog is the number 1 source for anti-anti-whaling information on the net. Whenever I see a good update from him, I post it in the news links. ;)
blog comments powered by Disqus