Creative Comic Conversations

February 17th, 2010

I recently had several classes re-caption several webcomics. I did this for a few reasons. Using comics in class to have students develop dialogue is far more interesting / engaging than asking them to roleplay what has already been written in the textbook. It’s also far more challenging due to its unfamiliarity. These students do not know the characters from the comic, have a mere 3 frames to grasp the context of the situation, and are often pressed to be super creative when faced with these issues. I love that. I thrive on that. I like to hear the gears in their heads whir as they do something out of the ordinary. Plus, it benefited me in a way, too – I also happened to use this activity as an example in a cruddy mediocre talk I gave at our prefectural midyear seminar to other high school ALTs.

I first got the idea for this project when I saw it pop up on the blog of a former CIR here in Ehime. His Japanese examples are pretty funny, by the way, though you can tell they’re a bit dated from the jokes (not just the URL)! Anyhoo, I then traced it over to this site, which is where I saw the potential for high school kids to pull it off.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with Penny Arcade, you really should be. It’s a hugely popular webcomic built around gamer interests that’s updated thrice weekly. The guys who make it, Mike & Jerry, rock out with their socks out, so go hit them up. Having said that, I feel like it’s important to offer up a note here. Note: Penny Arcade is NOT appropriate for class. The subject matter is super niche and the language alters between course, archaic, and highly sarcastic. The art, however, is perfect – highly emotive and often curious.

You can visit the source comics via the following links: 1, 2, 3, 4, & 5. That’s right. 5 comics. Examples follow. Please feel free to read them. Sorry about the poor legibility – the ditto machines are ancient at school. Ask questions and make comments if you’re so inclined! But above all else, enjoy.

  • Facebook
  • email
  • Technorati
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks

Deas Customary Drivel, Humor, Media, Photos

Hit JapanSoc.com today for the best social news about Japan!
Loading...
  • I guess it really says something about Penny Arcade that the second and third mushroom comics perfectly match the original ^_^

    Some of those are pretty great :) I'm thinking of "Santa Claus", "gained weight" and "he is gay!" :D
  • Tom
    These are great. You choose some really good strips to use as well. But yeah, I'm glad you didn't show them the original dialogue!

    I tried to do some of these a while back, but the results weren't as amusing as these. It's for things like this in class that I sometimes wished I was at a high school and not a JHS.
  • I think my favorite is the Tohoshinki one, mainly because it does such a good job of capturing the general spirit of the original, and consequently the dialog fits really well with the drawing, in all three panels. (No, I don't have any idea what Tohoshinki is. But it doesn't really matter.)

    Several of the others are interesting as well.

    I also think some old Sunday Calvin and Hobbes strips would work well for this exercise too.
  • Tohoshinki is a musical group from South Korea. (Apparently they're called 東方神起
    [Tohoshinki] in Japan, but are called 동방신기 [Dong Bang Shin Gi] in South
    Korea.) Wikipedia to the rescue! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TVXQ
  • I've done these sorts of activities before - They can be very fun. It's more effective if they have a lot of input to go on, though, or else the students might possibly make errors that stick with them; habitual mistakes.

    Some of your students have a great lexicon. Either that, or they have some pretty decent dictionaries - "declared my love for", "gained a little weight", "how do I know", "don't behave so childishly"...particularly the 'so' in the last one - It's a pretty abstract concept. Most students would mistakenly write, "don't behave too childishly."

    I haven't seen you in action, but I get the sense that you're in your element, Deas!
  • Myles
    This seems like a pretty cool exercise. Penny-Arcade is the best. Best one is where Luigi threatens to arrest Mario because he is an addict. So good. Second, definitely the one where one of your students plans on getting revenge.

    Also, I assume Metabo means fat in Japanese?
  • Ah - good catch - "metabo" is short for "metabolic syndrome," which indeed
    has come to mean "fat" in Japan. There's actually a legal definition for it
    now in terms of waistline, and if you exceed it there are fines and stuff,
    or so I hear. Totally Orwellian in my brain. I've never encountered it
    myself.....at least, I haven't encountered it yet...
blog comments powered by Disqus